| Redwing |
Well I searched a bit with little luck. I own an 01 MDX and will likely get a new one next year.
To you folks that have owned both, is the rear usable cargo area smaller on the 07's and on? I know that the dimensions are smaller, but I wonder if that is due to the roof line differences of the 2 models, hence I ask about "usable" room. Sorry if this should be in the comparo sections, as I wasn't sure where to put this. And yes, even I am looking at the Enclave as an option. I don't want too small a rear room- need to haul the dog crate and need room for that occasional 4some golf trips.
TIA |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by Redwing
Well I searched a bit with little luck. I own an 01 MDX and will likely get a new one next year.
To you folks that have owned both, is the rear usable cargo area smaller on the 07's and on? I know that the dimensions are smaller, but I wonder if that is due to the roof line differences of the 2 models, hence I ask about "usable" room. Sorry if this should be in the comparo sections, as I wasn't sure where to put this. And yes, even I am looking at the Enclave as an option. I don't want too small a rear room- need to haul the dog crate and need room for that occasional 4some golf trips.
TIA
Are you talking aft of the 2nd row or 3rd row? |
|
|
| Redwing |
Sorry I wasn't more clear. I'm more curious with the third row down and second row up configuration. I suspect that cargo room made available by lowering the second row is about the same for both or just slightly different.
But again, it would be the second row up and third row down comparison that is of most interest to me. And yes, it would be the USABLE room behind the second row with the third row down. |
|
|
| cybulman |
With the 3rd row down its a massive amount of space.
Cy |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by cybulman
With the 3rd row down its a massive amount of space.
Cy
I agree. I have yet to fill it. Suspect that only my week vacation in June will do so. |
|
|
| pbm317 |
I actually went on a road trip, me in my 07 MDX and my friends with their 06. The 06 has a taller roofline and could fit a lot more of the bulkier gear. There's still a lot of room in the 07, but the cargo area is a good amount taller in the pre-07 MDX's.
Both of us kept our 2nd rows up, 3rd rows down. |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
| I would have to disagree with the last post. I currently own an 01 and 07. The amount of space is comparable but the 07 has a narrower inlet and the middle space is compromised somewhat by the rear speakers. The roofline is deceptively lower owing to the overall lower stance of the 07. I also have an 07 Odyssey, and it spanks both X's as far as smart use of interior space, even with the third row UP. I can't even put a fullsize Graco stroller in either SUV whereas I can fit that, a smaller McLaren stroller, and groceries in the Ody with the third row up. |
|
|
| cybulman |
Needsdecaf...in fact it has sooo much space compared to my Touarge or Pathfinder...I returned Chicago to Dallas, put in big luggage for 2, Christmas gifts, two huge baby toys (swing and sleeper) a big cooler chest, 2 computer bags and still there was space and rear visibility.
Cy |
|
|
| craniotes |
I don't have a 1st generation MDX to compare mine to, but the rear cargo area was large enough to hold enough luggage for a week-long trip to Montreal over the summer for two adults and an eight month old baby (the latter of which actually requires more crap than the adults). We even brought along my son's Bugaboo Chameleon and exer-saucer. Everything fit, with nothing spilling over to the passenger compartment.
If you need more space, the only SUVs on the market currently that would fill the bill would be the Pilot, Expedition/Navigator, Land Cruiser/LX570, GM Lambdas, or GM Tahoe/Suburban/Escalade. All decent vehicles to be sure, but I guarantee none of them drive as well.
Regards,
Adam |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
I also have an 07 Odyssey, and it spanks both X's as far as smart use of interior space, even with the third row UP. I can't even put a fullsize Graco stroller in either SUV whereas I can fit that, a smaller McLaren stroller, and groceries in the Ody with the third row up.
You're comparing it to a minivan, what do you expect? Of course you're going to have WAY more room. |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
quote:
Originally posted by Needsdecaf
You're comparing it to a minivan, what do you expect? Of course you're going to have WAY more room.
I just wanted to plug in a vote for the real man's vehicle of choice. :2: What puzzles me is the use of the well behind the third row. I know the spare tire sits underneath, but if I had a choice, I would have designed the covered cargo area to be removable, and put the spare in the interior, off to the side. |
|
|
| pbm317 |
| spare tire wouldn't fit inside off to the side. it would encroach on the 3rd row area. |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
quote:
Originally posted by pbm317
spare tire wouldn't fit inside off to the side. it would encroach on the 3rd row area.
That's why I stated "I would have designed it" but then again I'm not an Acura engineer. As it is right now on the 07 with the third row up, you can barely fit a large piece of luggage and a carry-on on their sides, or 2 smaller pieces. With the third row down, it swallows a lot of stuff though. But then again in comparison, with the third row down on the Ody, you can carry a 7 foot Christmas tree by wedging the top between the adjustable second row captain's chairs. |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
That's why I stated "I would have designed it" but then again I'm not an Acura engineer. As it is right now on the 07 with the third row up, you can barely fit a large piece of luggage and a carry-on on their sides, or 2 smaller pieces. With the third row down, it swallows a lot of stuff though. But then again in comparison, with the third row down on the Ody, you can carry a 7 foot Christmas tree by wedging the top between the adjustable second row captain's chairs.
You must have never had / driven a car with the tire like this. I have - a Jeep Cherokee, and it was terrible. |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
quote:
Originally posted by Needsdecaf
You must have never had / driven a car with the tire like this. I have - a Jeep Cherokee, and it was terrible.
Actually, I'm driving one right now - the Odyssey's spare tire storage is either under the lazy susan compartment or the driver's side third row. It does impinge somewhat on that passenger's space but my daughter hasn't complained. It only fits a donut though, but the OEM spare on an MDX is a donut as well. |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
Actually, I'm driving one right now - the Odyssey's spare tire storage is either under the lazy susan compartment or the driver's side third row. It does impinge somewhat on that passenger's space but my daughter hasn't complained. It only fits a donut though, but the OEM spare on an MDX is a donut as well.
No, I was talking about on the side of the passenger compartment. |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
quote:
Originally posted by Needsdecaf
No, I was talking about on the side of the passenger compartment.
:confused: |
|
|
| Needsdecaf |
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
:confused:
Sorry, I quoted the wrong post.
My Grand Cherokee comment was in response to THIS post you made:
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
I just wanted to plug in a vote for the real man's vehicle of choice. :2: What puzzles me is the use of the well behind the third row. I know the spare tire sits underneath, but if I had a choice, I would have designed the covered cargo area to be removable, and put the spare in the interior, off to the side.
Side of the cargo area is a terrible place for the spare tire. |
|
|
| Redwing |
So DJ, since you own both, is the USABLE space in the 07 noticeably smaller? The amount in the 01 is fine with me. As I mentioned in the first post, I saw the new Cubic feet numbers and the 07 was smaller. Also, one of you mentioned other options and the Enclave should be in that list. I don't need tons of room, but the Lexus/Infiniti rides are likely too small. Not sure yet, but still scoping things out.
Thanks to those that offer opinions:7: |
|
|
| craniotes |
quote:
Originally posted by Redwing
Also, one of you mentioned other options and the Enclave should be in that list.
When I mentioned the "GM Lambdas", I was referring to all of the GM Lambda-bodied CUVs. In addition to the Saturn Outlook, GMC Acadia, and Chevrolet Traverse, this group also includes the Buick Enclave. Interestingly enough, the cheapest of the bunch -- the Traverse -- also has the most features (heated/cooled seats, blindspot warning, etc.), the most powerful engine (though all the Lambdas will be getting the new powerplant), and actually resembles an MDX from certain angles.
Regards,
Adam |
|
|
| Redwing |
quote:
Originally posted by craniotes
When I mentioned the "GM Lambdas", I was referring to all of the GM Lambda-bodied CUVs. In addition to the Saturn Outlook, GMC Acadia, and Chevrolet Traverse, this group also includes the Buick Enclave. Interestingly enough, the cheapest of the bunch -- the Traverse -- also has the most features (heated/cooled seats, blindspot warning, etc.), the most powerful engine (though all the Lambdas will be getting the new powerplant), and actually resembles an MDX from certain angles.
Regards,
Adam
oops. My eyes must have jumped that to the next GM group. I just missed it. |
|
|
| craniotes |
quote:
Originally posted by Redwing
oops. My eyes must have jumped that to the next GM group. I just missed it.
No worries, mate. However, be sure to check out the Traverse if you can wait until May (I think that's when it's going to be introduced). If you need more space than the MDX provides, and you don't mind sacrificing a bit (a lot) in terms of on-road prowess, this is the one to beat, IMO.
Regards,
Adam |
|
|
| dj-mdx2 |
quote:
Originally posted by dj-mdx2
I would have to disagree with the last post. I currently own an 01 and 07. The amount of space is comparable but the 07 has a narrower inlet and the middle space is compromised somewhat by the rear speakers. The roofline is deceptively lower owing to the overall lower stance of the 07. I also have an 07 Odyssey, and it spanks both X's as far as smart use of interior space, even with the third row UP. I can't even put a fullsize Graco stroller in either SUV whereas I can fit that, a smaller McLaren stroller, and groceries in the Ody with the third row up.
Redwing, this is my original post on it - may have gotten lost in the shuffle. You have to realize that I don't haul planks of plywood but I have put several bags of mulch, and I occasionally cart my 2 dogs (65 and 50 lbs) to the vet, several big cartons to the recycling unit, gobs of the usual kid stuff, and can still parallel park like a champ compared to those huge GM SUVs and pickups (which are the norm in my neighborhood) at my local school pickup line. :D
So you should be fine with a dog cart and 4 golf bags with the 3rd row down. Like I said the 07 does have a narrower inlet due to the sloping roof line and is constricted somewhat in the middle like a pelvic outlet obstruction (excuse the obstetrical term) by the rear speakers. But the usable space is very comparable in my experience. Hope that helps. |
|
|
| Redwing |
Thanks all,
Some good info above. I'm still biased towards the MDX, but I've got to keep the options open. Wife will likely make the choice, but I usually have good persuasion
skills on this choice. :)
When we got the 01 MDX, there weren't alot of options. We had to get the third row. Ironic that we were also looking at another Buick then too (Rendevouz.) We certainly made the right choice.
But, we (I) still want some cargo area with the second up or at least 1/2 the second row up. Kids are off to college, but the golfing group continues.:D
If I didn't have an 01, I wouldn't even be looking at this issue, but I do wonder how much cargo space I may be truly losing with the new design.
Again, thanks folks. |
|
|
| G. COLTON |
If you lose any because of a new design that is too much. My 2004 barely has sufficient room behind the second row seat. The third row seat, which I have never raised, takes up what should be good storage space beneath the floor. I have to carry a stowage box to make up for that deficiency. That does not leave much room for golf clubs or anything else.
Another problem is not so much space but width. Why put 48" between the wheel wells and not carry that width through the hatch? Some non-functional engineer wasn't thinking. Therefore I cannot carry a full sheet of plywood flat.
G |
|
|
|
